|
Extract
from "An Urgent Appeal to Friends" written on 10 July 2002 when
three friends from Bhopal were on hunger strike outside the Indian parliament
in New Delhi.
"Terrorism" is much
in the news. But there is another, less well-known species of terror:
that caused by the greed, negligence and ruthlessness of huge corporations.
Why did Carbide, ignoring the advice of its own experts, build its toxic
factory in the middle of densely populated neighbourhoods? Why, in contravention
of its own US safety standards, was such a huge quantity of methyl-isocyanate,
a chemical known to be lethal, stored on site? Why was the tank that ruptured
not being kept, as the safety manual required, at zero degrees C? Why,
on "that night" were the plant's back-up safety systems, such
as the "scrubber", semi-dismantled and not working? Why did
the alarm siren not immediately sound, offering a small chance to those
who heard it?
We know the answers to some of these questions from talking to people
who worked in the plant. The tank had not been refrigerated for some months,
in order to save 500 rupees a day on freon gas. 500 rupees is about £7,
or $11. The "scrubber" was in bits because parts of it had become
badly corroded and needed replacing, but the work had not been done. The
alarm siren stayed silent because it had been switched off. There had
been so many leaks of gas at the plant that the constant hooting had become
a nuisance. To other questions we have as yet no answer. These are the
questions that Carbide would have had to answer in court - if it had ever
showed up.
Carbide isnt charged with terrorism. But it might be if more people
knew what the terror in Bhopal was like. Indeed, what happened on "that
night" redefines the word.
Let me tell you about the night of December 2nd/3rd 1984. It happened
just after midnight, the unthinkable thing that had been coming, that
journalists and plant workers alike had predicted. A rumbling in the pipes,
the realisation that something had gone terribly wrong. Panic, then, and
the discovery that all the safety systems were down. Water had got into
the giant tank (the thing is the size of a large locomotive) containing
the methyl-isocyanate (MIC). A violent heat-producing reaction began and
as more water poured into the tank the fiercer grew the reaction. At high
temperatures MIC breaks down into other highly toxic chemicals, including
cyanides. The tank was buried in the ground, sealed under concrete, yet
so intolerable was its chemical indigestion that it burst out of the earth
and stood shuddering on end, emitting a stream of gas into the night.
Another stream poured from the half-dismantled "scrubber", and
was caught by the wind and flung towards the crowded neighbourhoods nearby.
In J.P.Nagar, Oriya Basti, Kainchi Chola, Kazi Camp, most people were
at home sleeping. The gases came into their houses without warning. They
woke choking, with their eyes and mouths burning. Nobody knew what had
happened. Then came shouts of "gas!" and "run away!"
and doors began opening, people tumbling out of their houses. The gas
was waiting for them, rolling in thick clouds along the narrow lanes,
which in some places were no more than four feet wide. The streetlamps
were shedding a tobacco-brown light. No insects whirled about them, they
were all already dead. As families picked up their toddlers and babies
and fled, the alleys became narrow stampedes of people and animals - cows
and dogs ran along with their owners - people fell and were trampled,
children were wrenched out of their mothers' arms and lost, never found
again. 8,000 people died very horribly, with piss and shit running down
their legs, their eyeballs white slits where the gases had bleached them.
The gases stripped the linings from their lungs, and they drowned in their
own fluids. Others had sudden convulsions and dropped in the street. The
city was full of dead bodies. Nobody knows exactly how many died, but
we can form an idea because 7,000 burial shrouds were bought over the
next three days. This does not take into consideration the hundreds of
people who were unaccounted for, or the families who had no-one left to
bury or cremate them. In the railway station, a whole tribe of gypsies
camped on one of the further platforms perished to the last soul. Not
one of their names is known.
By morning the hospitals were full of desperately ill people, coughing
up their lungs, many unable to see. The doctors did not know how to treat
them, since nobody knew what exactly what had poisoned them, and Carbide
was not saying. It is a fair certainty that cyanide was involved, the
antidote to which, sodium thiosulphate, was available. Lives which could
have been saved were lost. But the survivors were soon to regard those
who had died as the lucky ones. Though none of them knew it, their immediate
suffering was only the beginning. Half a million people were injured by
breathing the gases, many were left so badly disabled that they would
never work again. Their families became destitute, reduced to beggary
- some of the worlds poorest people destituted by one of the world's richest
corporations. Surely there'd be hell to pay. Someone's head would surely
roll. The compensation, and the responsibility of caring, for the rest
of their lives, for the injured would surely empty even Carbide's huge
coffers. You'd think so, wouldn't you?
On "that night" in Bhopal, three times as many people died as
were killed in New York on September 11th. The Bhopalis were just as innocent
and unsuspecting as the office workers whose lives ended so brutally in
the Twin Towers. They too had done nothing to deserve such a terrible
fate. But no crusade was launched, no rock concert was staged for their
benefit, no ageing rock stars queued on stage to sing songs about "freedom".
After September 11, there was a massive appeal for donations, leading
to compensation payments of over $1,000,000 to relatives of the victims
in recognition of the stress they had suffered. The families of Bhopal's
dead were paid $1250 per corpse. Of the injured, those who have received
anything at all, got on average just $500. During the Exxon Valdez disaster,
Alaskan sea-otters were kept glossy by feeding them fresh lobster at the
cost of $500 per day per otter. "The life of an Indian citizen in
Bhopal," commented the Times of India, "is clearly much cheaper
than that of a sea otter in America".
Read
the original letter which was sent as an email to the author's
friends with a request to relay it onward. It had travelled twice round
the world within a week.
You can also read it as
published in the New
Internationalist, ZNet,
Just Response
(Italy), Outlook
India, LabourNet,
UK Indymedia,
Safe2Use.com and elsewhere.
|